Is your email marketing as effective as it could be? I receive a lot of email marketing blasts and have noticed a pattern of consistent mistakes. This brief guide identifies five common pitfalls and offers suggestions on what to do instead.
1. Weak Subject Lines
By far the most important part of your email marketing message is the Subject Line. Since we all receive more email than we have time for, readers are looking for an excuse to delete emails towards their quest for in-box zero. I see too many Subject Lines that are not intriguing enough to get the reader to open. If your email isn’t opened, then all the time you’ve spent crafting the interior message is wasted.
The Subject Line must offer a compelling promise to readers that will be fulfilled upon opening the email. The Subject Line should focus on how the reader will benefit from the information contained within the email. For example, the Subject Line of this e-mail “5 Email Marketing Mistakes To Avoid ” offers free advice to make you more savvy in your use of email marketing.
2. Content That Doesn’t Offer Value
I see a lot of email blasts that are simply Project Completion Announcements. Good news is always worth sharing with your audience. Just be sure to make a connection between the news item and how it benefits the reader. For example, focus on what you learned from the completed project and how this will benefit the reader (who is hopefully a future client).
Just like the person who is always telling you how great they are, e-mail blasts that are about me, me, me get old quick. Aim for a balance of content that is 20% about you and 80% for the reader. Be generous in sharing knowledge, tips, secrets, and solutions for making the reader better, smarter or faster.
3. Brand Inconsistency
Too many e-mail blasts don’t look or sound like the firm that is sending them. This lack of continuity causes confusion for the reader and may plant a seed of doubt as to the authenticity of the blast. Your e-mail blasts must have the same look and feel as your website, business card and all other marketing materials.
It may be tempting to use a free template that your email service provider offers. But your firm offers custom professional services so your email blasts should reflect that. Hire a professional designer to create a template that you can then update for subsequent blasts.
4. Neglecting the Preview Window
Most people decide whether or not to read your email based on the following ritual. They scan the “From” line to determine if they know and trust you. The next hurdle is the “Subject” line. If it is intriguing, then the reader will scan the “Preview Window” to ensure the content fulfills the promise of the subject line. Too many email blasts neglect the top 4 inches of the email message (that shows up in the preview window). This valuable real estate needs to 1) establish trust by displaying your brand identity 2) be visually interesting so the reader wants to go deeper.
5. An Overwhelming Sea of Text
Perception is reality. An email blast that seems like it will require a lot of effort to read is immediately judged as work and we’ve all got plenty of that to do already. If you have a lot of content, then post the first paragraph to hook the reader and include a link to read the whole story on your blog. Another approach is to offer the text in digestible bites. Make the text scannable with bold headlines and then a few sentences of supporting text. Don’t forget to include compelling imagery. Photography or illustration will quickly draw someone into your content. It can also add additional meaning and make your content more memorable.
As a marketer, I know your time and resources are limited. The previous tips will help you get the most return on your email marketing investment. Feel free to add me, david (at) lecoursdesign.com, to your mailing list. I’d love to see what you create.
Quick Tips
Write 10 possible Subject Lines for your blast and pick the most compelling one
In developing content for your blast, keep asking how your reader will benefit
Break up lengthy text into digestible sections and use imagery to keep readers engaged
Digging Deeper
Tips on Writing Magnetic Headlines (applies to Subject Lines too) from Copyblogger
LecoursDesign helps firms create compelling email marketing campaigns
Email Marketing: Getting Readers to Open





Let’s Connect